Who said that the real tragedy of life is getting what you want? Lucy Angatel invites Hercule Poirot to dinner. Wanting to prank the famous detective, her guests stage a fake murder by the pool. Unfortunately, however, the victim does not play the game! As his blood drips into the water, John Christow whispers one last word: "Henrietta." In the confusion, a gun ends up at the bottom of the pool. Poirot's investigations will uncover a complicated carousel of family secrets and love affairs. It seems that everyone in this story is both a suspect and a victim; victims of love!